I have been involved with appraisal since 2003 initially as a GP appraiser, then GP appraisal lead and culminating in my role as GP Responsible Officer for Wolverhampton. I have always felt that it was a privilege being an appraiser and to have educational conversations with colleagues not only helping them navigate through challenging times but also learning from them. This learning is further emphasised by the GMC who clearly state that appraisal is not a ‘pass or fail’ exercise but developmental. Scotland has a system in place which is the envy of many not only in the UK but internationally. A national SOAR system with dedicated staff headed by William Liu is the centre piece to ensure quality and consistency in appraisal processes across all specialties.